Between the Civilian and Military Worlds
Abingdon, Oxon; New York: Routledge, 2022. 262 pp.
Edited by: Eyal Ben-Ari and Vincent Connelly
Reviewed by: Jodie Lording
Contemporary Military Reserves: Between the Civilian and Military Worlds is an ambitious and thoughtful contribution to the sociology of military reserve service. Bringing together 12 chapters organised across four thematic sections, the volume seeks to move reserve forces out of the margins of military scholarship and place them at the centre of debates about force design, legitimacy and civil–military relations.[1] Rather than treating reservists as latent workforce pools, the editors frame reserve service as a socially embedded practice, shaped by identity, obligation and negotiation across civilian and military domains.[2]
The conceptual backbone of the book lies in two integrative ideas articulated in the introduction: reservists as ‘transmigrants’ who move repeatedly between civilian and military worlds, and the existence of multiple formal and informal contracts that bind reservists not only to the state but also to employers, families and communities.[3] These concepts give the volume a coherence often lacking in edited collections and encourage the reader to think about reserve service as relational and negotiated rather than purely institutional. Importantly, the editors do not present these ideas as a rigid framework but as sensitising concepts through which diverse national cases can be read comparatively.
One of the book’s most consistent arguments is that integration between regular and reserve forces cannot be achieved solely by the declaration of policy on the topic. Across a number of author contributions, integration emerges as uneven, fragile and contingent on local practice. Canadian and British cases, for example, demonstrate how organisational charts and reform rhetoric frequently obscure persistent cultural differences between regular and reserve forces at unit level. Integration, where it occurs, is shown to depend less on formal structures than on trust, prior service histories and informal accommodations. This finding has clear resonance for the Australian Defence Force (ADF). The language of the Total Workforce System (TWS) similarly promises seamless integration, yet Contemporary Military Reserves suggests that, without sustained attention to how integration is enacted in practice, such promises risk remaining aspirational rather than realised.
A second, and more unsettling, theme concerns the cumulative cost to reservists of inhabiting multiple identities. Reservists can be understood as social and organisational hybrids—simultaneously soldiers and civilians, positioned both within and outside the military system and committed to each sphere, while also continually moving between military and civilian contexts. The chapter examining the United States Army Reserve and National Guard is particularly informative. By linking identity, health and wellbeing, the authors show how repeated transitions between civilian employment and military service generate identity strain for individuals over time. This pressure is intensified by the National Guard’s dual role as both a war-fighting force and a domestic emergency responder. While the US federal–state context is distinctive, the underlying dynamic is not. Australian reservists have increasingly been mobilised or employed for domestic crises—from the 2019–20 bushfires to pandemic response to cyclones and floods—often without adequate policy provisions to support their recovery before returning to civilian work. The book implicitly raises a question that remains largely unanswered in Australian policy: how much strain can a reserve force absorb before goodwill, wellbeing and retention begin to erode?[4]
If identity and wellbeing form one analytical axis of the volume, employer relations and skill transfer form another. Several chapters interrogate the (now familiar) assumption that reservists’ civilian skills can be readily translated into military capability. The United Kingdom case is particularly revealing in this regard. Despite strong enthusiasm at the policy level for harnessing civilian expertise, the evidence suggests that such skills are unevenly recognised, poorly mapped to military roles and frequently constrained by organisational culture. Employers, while rhetorically supportive, face real costs when reservists are mobilised repeatedly, and institutional mechanisms to mitigate these costs are often underdeveloped.[5] For Australia, where the TWS relies heavily on the presumed portability of civilian skills and employer goodwill, these findings function as a caution. The volume proposes a meaningful argument that skill transfer requires active institutional mediation rather than reliance on informal arrangements or goodwill alone.
The most conceptually rich material appears in the Israeli case studies, where reserve service is embedded within a broader social covenant between citizens and the state. Here, the transmigrant concept is explored not merely as an analytical metaphor but as a lived reality shaped by obligation, legitimacy and collective memory.[6] While Australia’s strategic environment and mobilisation needs differ markedly from Israel’s, the contrast is instructive. The Israeli case demonstrates what is largely absent in many other contexts: an explicit articulation of what the state owes its reservists in return for repeated service. For the ADF, this raises an uncomfortable but important question. Beyond contractual arrangements, what covenant—if any—supports Australia’s growing reliance on reserve soldiers?
Notably, the book does not seek to reconcile the tension between high-obligation and low-obligation reserve systems. Instead, it allows these models to sit uneasily alongside one another. Reserves are expected to be simultaneously flexible, cost-effective and rapidly deployable, while remaining firmly embedded in civilian life. The volume documents the consequences of this contradiction without resolving it. This restraint is analytically honest, though readers seeking prescriptive solutions may find it frustrating. At the same time, it stresses the difficulty of treating reserve forces as a universal solution to contemporary defence challenges.
From an Australian perspective, one absence is striking. Although Australian scholars are cited throughout the volume—including Mark Armstrong; Samantha Crompvoets; Jodie Lording; Geoff Orme and E James Kehoe; Hugh Smith and Nick Jans; and Brad West—there is no Australian-authored chapter.[7] This omission reflects a deeper structural issue rather than editorial oversight. More than a decade ago, Jans characterised the state of military sociology in Australia as underdeveloped and institutionally fragile.[8] While dated, his critique remains pertinent. Australia has yet to build a sustained research community of military sociologists capable of contributing systematically to comparative studies of reserve service.[9] As a result, Australian experiences appear to be acknowledged but not fully represented in international scholarship.
Despite this limitation, Contemporary Military Reserves makes a significant contribution. Its value lies not in offering a blueprint for reserve reform but in reframing how reserve service is understood. By foregrounding identity, obligation and negotiation, the book challenges militaries to confront the social realities that underpin part-time service. For the ADF, the implications are substantial. If reservists are indeed transmigrants, policies premised on flexibility and goodwill require stronger institutional support. If employer cooperation is essential, it cannot be assumed.[10] And if reserve service is to remain sustainable, the informal contracts binding reservists to the Australian Defence Organisation must be made visible, credible and reciprocal.
In summary, this volume deserves close attention from Australian policymakers, scholars and practitioners concerned with the present and future of reserve forces. It is analytically rigorous, conceptually ambitious and quietly challenging. At the same time, its omissions—particularly regarding Australia—highlight the need for greater domestic investment in military sociology. Until that gap is addressed, Australia’s reserve—and arguably regular—experience will continue to be discussed through the lenses of others rather than articulated on its own terms.
Endnotes
[1] The volume’s sections are: ‘Between Military and Civilian Spheres’, ‘Identity and Motivation’, ‘Transferring Skills’ and ‘Political Dimensions’. The contributions include nationally grounded studies from the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Israel, Argentina, South Korea and Estonia, alongside a chapter examining reserve forces through NATO’s approach to total defence. Together, these contributions demonstrate a comparative reach beyond the usual Anglophone focus, even as much of the empirical weight remains transatlantic. Eyal Ben-Ari and Vincent Connelly, ‘Contents’, in Eyal Ben-Ari and Vincent Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves: Between the Civilian and Military Worlds (Abingdon, Oxon; New York: Routledge, 2022), p. vii.
[2] See Ben-Ari and Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves.
[3] See ibid., ‘Introduction: Negotiating Reservists: Transmigration and Multiple Contracts’.
[4] Australian scholars cited in the volume address this issue intermittently; however, their work does not yet constitute a clearly identifiable or sustained academic focus.
[5] On employer relations and the limits of civilian skill transfer, see Rachel Woodward et al., ‘Civilian Skills and Military Needs: The Case of the United Kingdom’, in Ben-Ari and Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves; Eleri Lillemäe, Taavi Laanepere and Kairi Kasearu, ‘Multiple Contracts Concept as Opportunity to Ease Challenges for Estonian Employers’ Obligations Concerning Employees’ Reserve Service in Military’, in Ben-Ari and Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves.
[6] Nir Gazit, Edna Lomsky-Feder and Eyal Ben-Ari, ‘Covenants and Contracts: The Israeli Reserve System’, in Ben-Ari and Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves. See also Edna Lomsky-Feder, Nir Gazit and Eyal Ben-Ari, ‘Reserve Soldiers as Transmigrants’, Armed Forces & Society 34, no. 4 (2008): 593–614.
[7] In the introduction, the editors explicitly cite Australian scholarship by Crompvoets (2013), Lording (2015), Smith and Jans (2011) and West (2018); other Australian authors appear only later in the volume. Ben-Ari and Connelly (eds), Contemporary Military Reserves, p. 1.
[8] Nick Jans, ‘The Sorry State of Military Sociology in Australia’, Australian Defence Force Journal 175 (2008): 43–50.
[9] The Australian Defence College has made substantive progress in developing a research community of practice (CoP) for doctoral candidates and graduates to facilitate information sharing and peer support. This CoP extends well beyond military sociology to include research across a wide range of disciplines relevant to Defence.
[10] Brad West and Josh Healy found that Australian civilian employers had ‘limited appreciation’ for the ‘transferability of skills attained through reserve service’, with some Army reservists ‘frequently’ experiencing hostility, sanctions and discrimination in their civilian workplaces. See ‘Executive Summary’, in Brad West and Josh Healy, Drawing on Reserves: Assessing Civilian Employer/Manager Support for Employees’ Part-Time Military Service, Australian Army Occasional Paper No. 28 (Australian Army Research Centre, 2025).