McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2023, ISBN: 9780228019299, 454pp RRP $95.00AUD (paperback)
Editors: Joakim Berndtsson, Irina Goldenberg and Stéfanie von Hlatky
Reviewed by: Matthew Jones
Joakim Berndtsson, Irina Goldenberg and Stéfanie von Hlatky’s 2023 edited volume Total Defence Forces in the Twenty-First Century offers a timely examination of how modern defence organisations are broadening their approach to national security beyond the regular military. Focusing on ‘total defence’ as a concept, the book explores integration across full-time military, reserve forces, civilian personnel and private contractors. Through comparative case studies, the contributors highlight the cultural, structural and institutional challenges of forging a unified defence enterprise. The contributors argue that harnessing all of these elements is essential in an era when threats range from great-power conflict to pandemics and natural disasters. The book’s overarching message—that defence is a whole-of-nation endeavour, not the sole preserve of full-time soldiers—resonates strongly with the Australian Army’s current focus on flexible force generation and national resilience.[1]
The editors describe a ‘total defence force’ (TDF) as a holistic defence workforce encompassing not only regular armed forces but also reservists, defence civilians, and contractors.[2] This concept signals a shift away from viewing defence as the military’s exclusive domain towards a ‘whole-of-society’ approach. Contemporary threats—from hybrid warfare and terrorism to pandemics and natural disasters—demand capabilities and expertise beyond what regular forces alone can provide. Many countries have adopted integration models such as the UK’s ‘Whole Force’,[3] the US’s ‘Total Force’[4] or Canada’s ‘Defence Team’[5] to better blend military sub-organisations and personnel groups. Crucially, the editors observe two core implications of the TDF approach. First, defence is no longer the purview of uniformed militaries alone; a broad spectrum of civilian agencies, industries and auxiliary personnel must be integrated, forcing militaries to share expertise and status with new partners. Second, this emphasis on integration raises challenging questions about organisational culture and group identity—how can disparate groups cooperate effectively, and what are the limits of intergroup collaboration? Throughout the volume, these themes recur as contributors examine the interplay of full-time soldiers, part-time reservists, civil servants and private contractors within evolving defence structures. The scope of the book is so wide that it is impossible to discuss all the notable chapters contained within; below is a selection of the topics covered.
Sweden’s reactivation of its total defence concept—after years of focus on expeditionary missions—is chronicled by Louise Olsson and Chiara Ruffa. A significant issue proved to be retention and workforce diversity: expanding the force with conscripts and civilians meant confronting longstanding norms about who ‘fits’ in the military. Even with strong political backing, implementation was a struggle where military culture had not adjusted. This case offers a cautionary lesson for Australia: adopting a total defence model will require redefining career paths and creating flexible service options to attract and retain the broader talent pool needed for modern operations.
Another chapter shines a light on the ‘hybrid civilian’—defence civilians who operate alongside the military in deployed or critical roles. Sarah Jane Meharg’s analysis shows that these individuals often serve as bridges between the armed forces and the civilian world. They can liaise with other government agencies, NGOs or local communities in ways uniformed personnel sometimes cannot, thus adding agility in complex missions. However, Meharg also points out that these civilians inhabit a grey zone of identity, which can lead to misunderstandings or under-utilisation if military personnel are unsure how to incorporate them. The takeaway for an army like Australia’s is the importance of deliberately preparing and empowering such hybrid roles. Their contribution needs to be deliberately planned and valued as part of the total force.
The book does not shy away from the persistent tensions between full-time regulars and part-time reservists. Vincent Connelly’s study of the British Army reveals familiar frictions: regulars sometimes doubt reservists’ dedication or skills, while reservists often feel under-utilised. Connelly and, similarly, Howard Coombs in his Canadian case study, show that deliberate measures can narrow these gaps. Joint training, exchange postings, and updated policies that put part-timers on equal footing are among the practical steps they highlight. Both authors stress that proper integration is not achieved by proclamations alone—it requires persistent effort to break down biases and administrative barriers. For the ADF, the message is that cultural change and flexible personnel management are as important as structural reform in unifying the regular and reserve elements.
Total Defence Forces in the Twenty-First Century also touches on the role of private industry and contractors in the defence ecosystem. A chapter on private military and security companies by Michelle Jones acknowledges the specialised capabilities contractors provide, while warning of risks in over-reliance. Loss of in-house skills and unclear command authority are potential downsides. The lesson for Australia is that industry partners should be part of the total force, but with proper oversight and retention of core military expertise.
In its conclusion, the book’s editors pull together these various thematic threads and emphasise key lessons. The editors repeatedly underline the benefits of a diverse defence workforce (more perspectives, surge capacity) as well as the barriers that must be overcome (cultural differences, legal and bureaucratic hurdles). Their recommendation is for deliberate strategies to foster common purpose and trust. Senior leaders must champion an inclusive ‘one team’ ethos, and routines like joint training and personnel exchanges should become standard to break down stereotypes. For the ADF—striving to integrate better its regular, reserve and public service components—such insights validate current efforts and highlight that building true resilience means military and civilian contributors working hand-in-glove in any crisis.
Overall, this book is both informative and thought-provoking for Australian Army and Defence leaders, particularly those involved in force design, workforce strategy and civil–military coordination centred around the National Defence Strategy. It arrives at a moment when countries from northern Europe to the Indo-Pacific are re-evaluating how to mobilise all national assets for defence. The volume shows how allied nations are redefining their forces to be more flexible and inclusive, implicitly asking whether we in Australia are doing enough to break down our own silos and leverage all of our talent. The volume does not provide one-size-fits-all answers, but its comparative insights and real-world lessons can guide our thinking. As the Australian Army pursues greater adaptability, cultural integration and civil–military partnership, Total Defence Forces in the Twenty-First Century offers encouragement and concrete ideas. It affirms that many militaries are on a similar journey—and that with learning and adaptation, the goal of a truly integrated and resilient defence force is within reach.
Endnotes
[1] Australian Army, Australian Army Contribution to the National Defence Strategy 2024 (Australian Army, 2024).
[2] Joakim Berndtsson, Irina Goldenberg and Stéfanie Von Hlatky, ‘Introduction’, in Joakim Berndtsson, Irina Goldenberg and Stéfanie Von Hlatky (eds), Total Defence Forces in the Twenty-First Century (McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2023), p. 3.
[3] John Louth and Trevor Taylor, Beyond the Whole Force: The Concept of the Defence Extended Enterprise and Its Implications for the Ministry of Defence (RUSI, 2015).
[4] Ryan Kelty and Richard E Niemeyer, ‘Civilians in the US Military’s Total Force’, in Morten G Ender, Ryan Kelty, David E Rohall and Michael D Matthews (eds), Inclusion in the American Military: A Force for Diversity (Lexington Books, 2023).
[5] See Lise Arseneau and Amy Cameron, ‘The Composition of the Defence Team’, in Irina Goldenberg, Angela R Febbraro and Waylon H Dean (eds), The Defence Team: Military & Civilian Partnership in the Canadian Armed Forces & the Department of National Defence (Canadian Defence Academy Press, 2015).